
At the CoBS Global Alumni Meetup held in the summer of 2026, Hao Liang, Professor of Finance at Singapore Management University (SMU), incoming faculty member at Nanyang Technological University (NTU), Associate Editor at Management Science, and Finance Section Editor at the Journal of Business Ethics, presented his research on the role of informal institutions in shaping corporate behavior. Drawing on studies of culture, ideology, and trust, Liang challenged the idea that firms are guided solely by formal rules, regulations, and contracts. Instead, he argued that many important corporate decisions are also influenced by social norms, shared beliefs, and historically rooted institutions.
The starting point of the Prof. Hao Liang’s presentation was a distinction originally proposed by economic historian Douglas North between formal and informal institutions. Formal institutions include laws, regulations, contracts, and legal protections that structure economic interactions. Informal institutions, by contrast, encompass culture, religion, ideology, trust, and social norms. Although they are not codified in legal documents, they nonetheless shape expectations, influence behaviour, and help societies coordinate economic activity.
Hao Liang’s central argument was that understanding corporate sustainability, governance, and stakeholder relations requires looking beyond incentives narrowly defined. Traditional economic models often focus on how individuals respond to financial incentives. Informal institutions add another layer: they influence how individuals interpret those incentives, what behaviours they consider legitimate, and how they interact with others in situations where contracts cannot fully specify every obligation.
To illustrate this perspective, Liang presented recent research examining the long-term influence of Confucian culture on contemporary Chinese firms. The study measures cultural exposure through the historical presence of Confucian academies established during the Qing Dynasty, some three centuries ago. By linking the geographic location of modern corporate headquarters with the historical distribution of these academies, the research investigates whether deeply rooted cultural traditions continue to affect corporate behaviour today.
Confucianism and Stakeholder Relationships
The findings suggest that firms located in areas with stronger historical exposure to Confucian culture invest more heavily in stakeholder relationships. They show greater attention to employees, customers, suppliers, and broader social contributions. Importantly, Liang argued that these results should not be interpreted simply as evidence that Confucian culture makes managers more altruistic.
Instead, he proposed an institutional explanation based on trust and relational contracting. Firms invest in stakeholder relationships because long-term reciprocal interactions create value. In this interpretation, culture functions as a governance mechanism that supports cooperation even in the absence of formal contractual enforcement.
Ideology continues to influence economic outcomes decades later
A second study focused on ideology as another form of informal institution. Exploiting the ideological transition that followed China’s economic reforms in 1978, Liang examined how political leaders exposed to different ideological environments during their formative years later influenced corporate behaviour in the cities they governed. The analysis compared local leaders shaped primarily by Mao-era ideology with those whose formative years coincided with Deng Xiaoping’s reform period.
The results indicate that ideology continues to influence economic outcomes decades later. Firms operating in cities governed by leaders more strongly influenced by Maoist principles tend to exhibit greater stakeholder spending, stronger employee protections, higher levels of charitable giving, and narrower pay gaps between executives and employees. At the same time, they appear less internationally oriented than firms located in cities governed by leaders whose formative experiences were shaped by the reform era. These findings suggest that ideology acts as a cognitive framework through which decision-makers allocate resources and define priorities.
Creating value through hidden resources

Across both studies, a broader message emerged. Informal institutions are not historical relics. Cultural norms, ideological beliefs, and trust-based relationships continue to influence how organizations operate, how managers make decisions, and how firms interact with stakeholders. In many cases, these influences persist over remarkably long periods of time.
The discussion that followed explored several implications of this perspective. Participants debated the relationship between trust and rationality, and the mechanisms through which culture affects innovation and collaboration. Others questioned whether the influence of local culture may weaken as markets become more integrated and formal institutions become stronger. Liang acknowledged that market development can reduce reliance on informal mechanisms, but argued that cultural and ideological influences remain visible even in highly modernized contexts.
The conversation also touched on academic publishing and the growing importance of interdisciplinary sustainability research. Reflecting on his editorial experience, Liang noted that sustainability challenges increasingly require scholars to move beyond traditional disciplinary boundaries. Questions related to ethics, conservation, climate finance, and stakeholder governance often demand collaboration across fields and methodologies.
The presentation ultimately invited participants to reconsider a fundamental assumption in management research and practice. While organizations often focus on laws, incentives, and formal governance structures, many of the forces shaping corporate behaviour remain unwritten. Culture, trust, ideology, and social expectations may be harder to observe and measure, but they continue to influence how businesses create value, build relationships, and respond to societal challenges. Understanding these informal institutions may therefore be essential for understanding corporate behaviour itself.

Useful links:
- Link up with Prof. Hao Liang on LinkedIn
- Read a related post: Guanxi HRM: When relationships shape ethics at work
- Download this and other insights from the publication The Singapore Green Plan and the Future of Responsible Business Education
- Discover ESSEC Business School Asia-Pacific
- Apply for a program at ESSEC Asia-Pacific.
Learn more about the Council on Business & Society
The Council on Business & Society (CoBS), visionary in its conception and purpose, was created in 2011, and is dedicated to promoting responsible leadership and tackling issues at the crossroads of business, society, and planet including the dimensions of sustainability, diversity, social impact, social enterprise, employee wellbeing, ethical finance, ethical leadership and the place responsible business has to play in contributing to the common good.
- Follow the CoBS on LinkedIn
- Download magazines and learning content from the CoBS website downloads page.
Member schools of the Council on Business & Society.
- ESSEC Business School, France, Singapore, Morocco
- FGV-EAESP, Brazil
- School of Management Fudan University, China
- IE Business School, Spain
- Indian Institute of Management Bangalore, India
- Keio Business School, Japan
- Monash Business School, Australia, Malaysia, Indonesia
- Olin Business School, USA
- Smith School of Business, Queen’s University, Canada
- Stellenbosch Business School, South Africa
- Trinity Business School, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland
- Warwick Business School, United Kingdom.

Discover more from Council on Business & Society Insights
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
