Shengwen Li and Anthony Goerzen, Sobey Professor of International Business at Smith School of Business, explore how a Canadian NGO attempts to bring about real change to the lives of women working in the mining sector.

Empowering Women in Global Mining by Jordan Whitehouse. With kind acknowledgements to Smith Business Insight. 

If you’re concerned that minerals inside your phone or laptop fund armed conflicts, you should be, says Shengwen Li, a PhD candidate at Smith School of Business. But she says there’s another reason to care about the source of these metals: gender discrimination.

It’s no secret that some consumer products are packed with metals mined in developing countries such as the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) that finance armed groups in those countries. Most of the extraction activities are considered “artisanal mining” — a form that is labour-intensive and informal and that often uses basic extraction tools like pans and hand shovels.

Less known, however, is that while millions of women find subsistence employment in artisanal mining, gender discrimination, economic instability and gender-based violence are rampant in the sector. The multinational corporations behind some artisanal mining don’t help the situation, says Li. “They often reinforce these gender divisions of labour, leveraging gender discrimination to minimize production costs through global sourcing. And so female workers frequently find themselves trapped in a poorly paid job or insecure working conditions.”

All is not lost. As Li and Anthony Goerzen, Sobey Professor of International Business at Smith, reveal in a new study, two types of third-party interventions can go a long way towards ensuring gender equality in artisanal mining, the first link in a high-stakes global value chain.

NGO with Impact

Li and Goerzen came to this conclusion after taking a deep dive into a project launched by the Canadian-based non-governmental organization Impact in 2017 in Ituri, a province in eastern DRC. Ituri is rich in gold deposits but its artisanal mining sector deals with severe challenges, including interference by armed groups and an overwhelmingly macho mining culture.

Impact’s project, known as the Village Savings and Loan Association, invited women and men from across Ituri to join the association and make weekly contributions to savings pools. Members then decided where to direct the loans to fellow VSLA members. The initiative focused on enhancing financial and employment opportunities, promoting female leadership and fostering inclusion for all artisanal miners and community residents.

Li and Goerzen were curious to know the impact the VSLA had on women’s inclusion and empowerment and, more importantly, what drove that impact.

“So many interventions from NGOs or multinational companies or governments are practically driven, which means they often lack the robust and theoretical foundations to explain the mechanisms behind the interventions,” says Li. “That’s why sometimes they lead to inconclusive results or varying effects across different contexts. We didn’t want that.”

Striking Gold: Two strategies for boosting inclusion

When they looked at the VSLA’s track record closely, they identified two strategies that led to more women being included in mining activities and feeling empowered.

One, known in academic circles as a “conversion” intervention, doesn’t change existing norms in a community but leverages the ambiguity in them to promote gender equality. In Ituri, husbands wouldn’t generally allow their wives to be involved in a project such as a VSLA, but because it provided financial and employment opportunities to households struggling with poverty, the men tended to allow women to participate.

The other strategy, called a “layering” intervention, is similarly subtle in that it doesn’t change existing community norms but adds new ones. In Ituri, men don’t typically allow women to be in decision-making roles, but the VSLA was purposely designed with new guidelines to promote female leadership. From surveying participants, Li and Goerzen found that this layering approach made women feel empowered and that it promoted both economic and attitudinal changes among men and women.

Useful Links:

• Link up with Shengwen Li and Anthony Goerzen on LinkedIn
• Read a related article: Integrating Gender When Developing Large Infrastructure Projects
• Discover Smith School of Business
• Apply for the Smith MBA.

Learn more about the Council on Business & Society

The Council on Business & Society (The CoBS), visionary in its conception and purpose, was created in 2011, and is dedicated to promoting responsible leadership and tackling issues at the crossroads of business and society including sustainability, diversity, ethical leadership and the place responsible business has to play in contributing to the common good.  

• Follow the CoBS on X and LinkedIn
• Download this magazine and others from the CoBS website downloads page.

Member schools of the Council on Business & Society.

• ESSEC Business School, France, Singapore, Morocco
• FGV-EAESP, Brazil
• School of Management Fudan University, China
• IE Business School, Spain
• Keio Business School, Japan
• Monash Business School, Australia, Malaysia, Indonesia
• Olin Business School, USA
• Smith School of Business, Queen’s University, Canada
• Stellenbosch Business School, South Africa
• Trinity Business School, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland
• Warwick Business School, United Kingdom.